The Supreme Court on Thursday
questioned whether homebuyers should approach it directly under Article 32 of
the Constitution to resolve disputes arising from stalled housing projects,
instead of raising their grievances before the appropriate lower courts.
A
Bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant, along with Justice
Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, observed that the Supreme Court could not
be expected to adjudicate every dispute between homebuyers and builders.
“Under
Article 32, how many such matters are we going to resolve? Every dispute
against a builder, every failed project, will end up here. How are we going to
resolve it?” CJI Kant remarked during the hearing.
The
observations came during proceedings on a petition filed by homebuyers in a
stalled housing project in Sonipat, Haryana. They had approached the apex court
seeking protection from recovery proceedings initiated by the State Bank of
India (SBI) over loans taken to purchase flats in the Krishna Housing Scheme in
Sector 14.
The
homebuyers had entered into a tripartite arrangement with the developer and SBI
to finance the under-construction flats. Under the agreement, the bank was
required to release loan instalments in phases, depending on the progress of
construction.
However,
the developer allegedly failed to complete the project and was subsequently
admitted into insolvency proceedings before the National Company Law Tribunal
(NCLT).
The
petitioners told the court that they had neither received possession of their
flats nor the refunds assured under the insolvency proceedings. Despite this,
SBI had initiated recovery proceedings against them before a commercial court
in Saket, Delhi.
They
sought an interim stay on the recovery action and requested that their petition
be tagged with another pending matter concerning loans extended to builders.
CJI
Kant questioned why the homebuyers had not pursued their objections before the
commercial court, where the recovery proceedings were already pending.
“You
have filed a commercial suit? It is pending before the civil court. Raise all
your objections there,” he told the petitioners' counsel.
The
lawyer submitted that the buyers had already raised their objections before the
commercial court, but recovery proceedings were continuing. He also alleged
that the developer had failed to pay the six-monthly instalments of refunds
promised under the NCLT proceedings.
The
Supreme Court subsequently directed the commercial court to examine the
homebuyers' objections before allowing the bank to proceed with recovery.
In
its order, the Bench noted that SBI appeared to have disbursed loans to the
developer without corresponding progress in construction.
It
said the commercial court must first examine the contractual arrangement
between the bank and the builder, including whether the loan amounts had been
released in accordance with the tripartite agreement.
“In
our considered opinion, it is the duty of the court first to determine the
nexus between the builder and the bank authorities and to see whether the bank
disbursed the loan amount to the builder strictly in terms of the tripartite
agreement,” the court said.
The
Bench directed that no coercive recovery measures be taken against the
homebuyers until the commercial court determines whether they were actually in
default.